The Wellhouse Exorcism
PJ and Shanna are joined by family members, Laura and Ray, as well as various spook-masters, to talk about their haunted house stories and other creepy stories from around the world.
Interview with Kevin Paul
Author of the Haunted Hills and Hollows books!
Episode 7
The Dybbuk Box
We are joined by John to talk about the one and only Dybbuk box! We read excerpts from the eBay listing and determine whether it is a hoax or real! Unfortunately we had technical difficulties with John's mic and he becomes very quiet about 20 minutes in. Turn your speakers up for this one!
Episode 13
Robert the Doll
We talk about the second most famous haunted doll, Robert. Residing in Florida, this doll is linked to at least one death and has some very questionable origins. Is this doll really haunted? Is it the spirit of Gene Otto? Is it a hoax? We pass our judgement on this creepy, creepy, doll.
Episode 20
Gettysburg Mini Series Part 1
Join the team as we officially begin our deep-dive into Gettysburg's most haunted locations! This week's episode focuses on two inns, the Cashtown and the Farnsworth. With a background into the gross history of "medical care" post-battle, this is a gross yet insightful episode that we all enjoyed...except Ray.
Episode 22
Gettysburg Mini Series Part 3: Hotels, Colleges, and Orphanages, Oh My!
This week we talk about the Gettysburg College, Gettysburg Orphanage, and the Gettysburg Hotel. Stay tuned after the episode as we interview Amanda, one of Laura and Ray's friends who attended Gettysburg College and has some stories to tell!
Episode 23
Gettysburg Mini Series Part 4: An Uphill Battle and a War Chicken?
This week we talk about the battlefields. We delve into some famous locations such as Devil's Den, The Wheatfield, Little Round Top, and others as we discuss the horrors of war of the spirits who still walk these grounds. Laura tells an especially gruesome tale from one home's basement that will be sure to make your skin crawl!
Episode 29
PukwuPJ and Liminal Unlimited
This week, we have Liminal Unlimited joining us to talk about the Bridgewater Triangle! If you are unfamiliar with the podcast, it consists of Kyle (from Kyle's Creepy Thoughts segment on our show) and my sister, Jenny. We were on two of their episodes talking about Skinwalker Ranch earlier this year, so we were more than happy to be able to host them for an episode here!
Episode 30
PukwuPJ's Choice: Devil's Road
Shanna and PJ talk about a local legend featured in the book, Weird Pennsylvania - Devil's Road and the Skull Tree! Is it haunted? Is there a Cult House on the Land? Are the DuPont's members of the Illuminati? Some of these questions are answered in tonight's episode!
Episode 31
To Heck with Hell Town!
On this episode of The Wellhouse Exorcism, PukwuPJ and Shanna discuss the varied legends of Hell Town in Ohio. Let us take you on a historical trip, from the 1700's to the present day, with all the death, murder, governmental conspiracies, toxic waste, abandoned ghost towns, and urban legends that have come to create such an iconic place as Hell Town.
Episode 32
PukwuPJ's Choice: The Jersey Devil
That's right...we finally let PJ grab the wheel and take the show into cryptid territory. We are talking about The Pine Barrens and the mysterious Jersey Devil. Is it a monster? A large bird? Is it real at all? Let's dig deep and see what the research says!
Episode 40
Georgie Porgie, Shanna's Personal Storie
On this week's episode, Shanna decides to tell a personal story from her childhood that was mentioned in passing on this podcast last year. It is the full story of her brother's "imaginary" friend, Georgie. Added to this story is a little extra: a story of a haunting at Bloomsburg University! So listen along to this personal anecdote!
Episode 42
The Trans-Allegheny Lunatic Asylum
Join us on this episode as we break down all the information, history, and hauntings of the Trans-Allegheny Lunatic Asylum! Special thanks to Tim for being a fantastic guest researcher and for suggesting this episode, and a huge thanks for being a great fan of the show!
Episode 43
The Toadally Awesome Tale of Frog-or Lizard-Man
Shanna and PJ are back from their vacation with a silly story that has lasted over 100 years. Listen along to hear about the Lizardman and Frogman, found in PA, Ohio, Kentucky, and all the way down in South Carolina! Let us know what you think!
Episode 45
Eastern State Penitentiary Part 1
Laura and Ray are back and ready to help the team do a deep dive into the history of Eastern State Penitentiary. As part 1 of this mini series, the team visited the location and did much research to give you all a great listening experience. Enjoy the history of Eastern State!
Episode 46
Eastern State Penitentiary Part 2
Join us on this week's episode with special guest Carrie as she tells her stories of Eastern State. An expert in it all, she not only has good stories, but also has a deep understanding of the history and suffering that took place in this location. An added bonus is her own ghost story!
Episode 48
The Amityville Horror
Look out! PJ is in charge again! He's on a mission to redeem himself by talking about one of the most famous hauntings in America. From the mob to evil pigs, we cover it all!! Is it real or a massive hoax? Lets take a trip to Ocean Avenue, where we'll sit and talk with you about this iconic haunted house.
EPISODE 50!
An Interview with Para-Sabrina Beackley
Shanna and PJ are joined this week by psychic-medium Sabrina Beackley! With a book about to hit the shelves, she takes the time to sit down to a Zoom interview with us to tell us a bit about the novel she has authored, as well as some of her most memorable cases! Listen in for a firsthand account, and look for her book, "Haunted Freedom," coming to Amazon soon!
What a great 50th episode!
Episode 52
The Alvira Bunkers
Join Shanna and PJ on this episode for a historical look at Alvira, the town that no longer exists due to the government. We take you on a journey through the creation of an ordnance at the cost of a community, and the terrifying hauntings that happen there today due to macabre uses of the bunkers.
Episode 53
Halloween Mini Series 1: Annabel Lee & The Raven
"The death of a beautiful woman is, unquestionably, the most poetical topic in the world." E. A. Poe, Philosophy of Composition Happy Halloween! For this week's episode, Shanna is hosting a 3-part mini series of some of Poe's most iconic works. So, turn down the lights and turn up the sound, and be prepared to be chilled and thrilled by none other than Edgar Allan Poe!
Episode 54
Halloween Mini Series 2: The Tell-Tale Heart
"I became insane, with long intervals of horrible sanity." E.A. Poe, from a letter to George Washington Eveleth Join Shanna in this next edition of her 3-part mini series. On this episode, she performs a dramatic reading of "The Tell-Tale Heart," written by Edgar Allan Poe. Listen closely, and if you hear a heart beat in your own home, beware!
Episode 55
Halloween Mini Series 3: The Masque of the Red Death
"Believe nothing you hear, and only one half that you see..." E.A. Poe, from The System of Doctor Tarr and Professor Fether On this last episode of this 3-part mini series, Shanna reads "The Masque of the Red Death." An iconic and haunting tale, it has its own connection to our modern pandemic. Be careful of ebony clocks and masked figures at your Halloween parties this evening!
Episode 56
A Collection of True Scary Stories
On this episode, Shanna reads some true scary stories submitted to various novels written by award-winning authors, including Mark Nesbitt! PJ is also excited to hear about his favorite cryptid. So, listen along to hear some truly terrifying and mysterious stories from around our area!
Episode 58
The Massacre of an Entire Nation
On this episode, Shanna and PJ offer a deep dive into the massacre of the entire Susquehannock Native American Nation. A gruesome part of early Pennsylvania history, it is a story largely secreted away as a dark moment in early colonial history. This episode connects directly to the podcast FullSendRejects, so please listen to their current series to hear our crossover!
Episode 60
Mad Anthony Wayne's Bones - Let's Dig INN!
On this episode, Shanna tells the story of "Mad Anthony" Wayne of Revolutionary War renown, his gross bones story, as well as the General Wayne Inn. This Inn, once located outside of Philadelphia, was one of the most haunted locations in Pennsylvania. The amount of ghost stories that exist from this Inn is INN-sane!
Episode 63
Spas and Lighthouses, But No Alligators
Welcome back to a new year! To start the year off right, Shanna recounts some haunted locations in Daytona, FL area, a place she, PukwaPJ, Laura, Ray, and the kids stayed over their Disney holiday! There are no spooky alligator stories though, much to Shanna's chagrin.
Episode 64
Screaming Ladies and Faceless Men: Fort Mifflin
On this week's episode, Shanna and Pukwa PJ tackle the famous Fort Mifflin. With its history rooted in the Revolutionary War, the Civil War, WWI, and WWII, there are many eras of ghosts to cull through. Listen in for a discussion about all the famous ghosts in this location, one of the only preserved sites of the Revolutionary War!
Episode 65
Flying Creatures are so COOL!
Shanna and PukwaPJ talk flying creatures tonight! In what will be the beginning of a longer discussion of aliens, Shanna starts off with a Mothman sighting in just this past decade, and then she goes right into multiple UFO/UAP sightings in PA! There is definitely something out there, so look up and be safe! Please find us on Facebook, Instagram, and Reddit! r/Thewellhouseexorcism to share your stories! gamesoverboard.com And as always, think spooky thoughts!
Episode 66
A Hudson River Haunting
It is once again Pukwa PJ's choice! He has chosen the story of the famous house from New York that forced the creation of a law that requires home owners to disclose their house as haunted to potential buyers. So, listen in for some creepy stories about the famous haunted house overlooking the Hudson River!
Episode 68
The Wicked Wendigo: It's Not a 10-Point Buck!
Join Shanna and Pukwa PJ this week as they unpack the legends and various versions of the wendigo. From Algonquin stories to the Lenape's version, Shanna presents her research on the wendigo, and even explains how to protect oneself from it. So, listen in for some really gross and creepy stories about cannibalism!
Episode 69
The Bennington Triangle
I'm Not Saying It's Bigfoot, But It's Bigfoot
On this week's episode, Shanna and PukwuPJ head off to Vermont to discuss The Bennington Triangle. Similar to the Bridgewater Triangle, this location is rife with missing persons, murder, and creepy creatures. Listen in for a crazy story!
Episode 70
"Upstate" New York
On this episode, Shanna and PukwuPJ are joined by Carrie and Tom for a close look at "Upstate" New York (whatever that means!)! We discuss two haunted locations in the Catskills and the Hudson Valley, and Carrie brings in some first-person UFO accounts! So join us for some poltergeists, ghosts, murder, and aliens!
Episode 71
The Conne-WHAT?
On this week's episode, Shanna analyzes the Conneaut Lake Hotel and Amusement Park in western PA. With a multitude of disasters like fires and tragedies, this hotel has many ghostly presences to unpack. PukwuPJ also shares a spooky event that happened while recording HIS podcast this week! So, listen in for some first-hand spooky experiences!
Episode 73
Break out the Green Shamrocks, But Run from the Leprechauns!
Happy Saint Patty's Day! For this special episode, Shanna will be talking about leprechauns, their heritage, and their connections to Tommy Knockers in Western Pennsylvania. So, get your green and shamrocks! It's gonna be a blast!
Episode 75
Jackie is on the MIB Watch List
On this episode, PukwuPJ, Shanna, and Nurse Jackie put on their tin foil hats and talk aliens! With her long background in military bases, self-proclaimed "Area 51 Expert Jackie" takes us on a quest to understand Area 51. However, if you never hear from us again, it is definitely because Jackie is in the MIB Watch List!
Episode 76
The Macbre Madame of New Orleans
This week we discuss the monstrous acts of Delphine LaLaurie who tortured and killed countless slaves in her home in New Orleans. How much of it was real and how much is overblown rumors? Is the house haunted with the spirits of those who died there? We try to find the facts and uncover the truth of this horrifying story.
Episode 77
Lake Erie and South Bay Bessie
On this episode, Shanna tries to prove the existence of a sea monster living in the depths of Lake Erie, while PuwuPJ tries to debunk it the whole time. So, listen in and make your own decisions on whether Lake Erie has something creepy lurking in its depths!
Episode 78
The Pittsburgh Playhouse
Interested in a spooky, historical location? Look no further than the Pittsburgh Playhouse. Once the site of many ghostly apparitions, it makes for a great creepy tale late at night! Join Shanna and PukwuPJ on this episode as they uncover the secrets of these ghosts!
Episode 79
The Smurl House: No Smearing Here!
On this episode, PukwuPJ takes control to tell the horrifying story of the years-long haunting of the Smurl House in Pittston, PA. With all the signs of demonic oppression and the terrorizing of the house's inhabitants, this makes for a truly creepy listen. A cautionary note to sensitive listeners, this episode vaguely discusses items that may be traumatic for some listeners. Please be prepared.
Episode 80
Topeka State Hospital
On this episode, Shanna tells the tragic tale of Topeka State Hospital. With corrupt government officials who allowed terrible crimes to happen, to unfortunate souls falsely imprisoned behind its walls, Topeka State Hospital has all the makings of a sordid and sad business that opens itself up for hauntings to abound. Listen in for the tragedy of Topeka State.
Episode 81
The Haunted RMS Queen Mary
On this episode, Shanna once again delves into the murky waters of haunted ships. As the last stop on haunted boats, she has chosen a doozy: The RMS Queen Mary. This ship has the possibility of at least 150 different spirits living on deck. So, listen in as she breaks down the most notable ones for PukwuPJ.
Episode 82
Alcatraz Series: Part 1
On this opening episode, Shanna and PukwuPJ take a leap onto THE ROCK. This Part 1 of our Alcatraz series focuses on the Native American beliefs of the island, the Alcatraz Fortress, and the beginnings of hauntings during the running of the prison. A spooky place, this prison has so much history to unpack, so listen in for just the beginning of a great series!
Episode 83
Alcatraz Series: Part 2
It is time for part 2 of our Alcatraz series! On this episode, Shanna and PukwuPJ discuss daily life at Alcatraz for inmates which was no easy walk in the part. They also discuss famous inmates who were sent there, like Al Capone, George "Machine Gun" Kelly, and the Birdman of Alcatraz. Finally, Shanna and PukwuPJ begin the stories of all the famous escapes! So, listen in for this next installment of Alcatraz!
Episode 84
Alcatraz Series: Part 3
On this finale to the Alcatraz series, Shanna and PukwuPJ tell the stories of other memorable escapes and of the hauntings that exist inside this one bustling prison. Terrifying while in operation and terrifying still, these ghost stories are sure to spook our listeners!
Episode 85
Deja Vu and Dreams
We are joined by our Paranormal Expert Carrie this week as we tackle our unconscious! On this episode, we take a close look at what Deja Vu, night terrors, and dream symbols. We also have an update on two haunted houses in our area! So, listen in and then send us your thoughts!
Episode 86
Lizzie Borden Part 1
On this episode, we begin a three-part series on the infamous Lizzie Borden. Shanna and PukwuPJ are joined by Paranormal Expert Carrie and our new Psychological Liaison Penny to uncover details about Lizzie Borden and her family. Utilizing the newest theories, a psychological analysis, and a discussion of the general Victorian beliefs as a backdrop, we as a team attempt to figure out why exactly Lizzie Borden may have been compelled to murder her family. Warning: Please note that listener discretion is advised.
Episode 87
Lizzie Borden Part 2
Shanna and PukwuPJ are once again blessed to have psychological expert Penny and paranormal expert Carrie on to help unfold the murders of Lizzie's parents. On this second part of our three-part series, we look at the weeks leading up to the murders as well as the grisly details of the murders themselves. PukwuPJ also decides to voice Lizzie Borden, so prepare yourselves for a vocal treat!
Episode 89
Lizzie Borden Part 3
The final episode in our three-part series on Lizzie Borden ends with a thorough look at the trial, biased Victorian views, and Lizzie's later life after her acquittal. Joining us for this episode are psychological expert Penny, paranormal expert Carrie, and medical expert Jackie! It's a full house and a full episode. Enjoy our longer episode, as we needed to include an extra 30 minutes to truly cover all the material. Whether you are #TeamLizzieDidIt or #TeamLizzieDidntDoIt, there is something for everyone in this episode!
Episode 90
The Crescent Hotel
For our episode 90, we decided to head down to Arkansas to the Ozark Mountains for some of those healin' waters! The Crescent Hotel is a spooky place with a long, riddled history. From death during the building of the hotel to an evil con-man doctor who killed hundreds of cancer patients, the Crescent Hotel is now home to many ghosts, some friendly, some not. Listen in for some creepy stories!
Episode 91
Pennhurst Lockdown Investigation Part 1
After spending about 7 hours at Pennhurst Asylum for a lockdown, PukwuPJ, Carrie, Tom, and Shanna have lots of paranormal experiences to present to our listeners! For this part 1, we offer some of our Estes sessions and two EVPs. You will hear our very first Estes session which is in the Mayflower Building first floor which includes a captured EVP, one of the two Estes sessions in the Infirmary Dentist Room which also includes a clear EVP, and we finish with our Estes session in the Quaker Building, first floor. And, fun fact, even in the afterlife, bacon is life!
Episode 92
Pennhurst Lockdown Investigation Part 2
This is our second installment of data from our paranormal investigation at Pennhurst during their first ever Quaker Lockdown. On this episode, you will hear 3 EVPS and 3 separate Estes Sessions. We can officially say that Pennhurst is incredibly haunted! We truly enjoyed our time there, and we look forward to returning in the future!
Episode 93
The USS Nimitz: A Guest Interview!
Long-time listener Stephen Smith joins Shanna and PukwuPJ on this episode to offer firsthand experiences of the haunted USS Nimitz. An amazing vessel still in active use today, this carrier has some haunted history, a serial killer onboard, and is also the location of the famous tic-tac video released in 2017! Listen in to hear from our guest about all the spooky happenings!
Episode 94
The House of Many Stairs and the Underground Railroad: Part 1
On this exciting mini-series, our Wellhouse Team was invited into The House of Many Stairs for a private tour and interview on the hauntings of this historical home. For part 1, Shanna sets up the historical backdrop of the Underground Railroad and the surrounding area's connections to it. This episode covers the Susquehanna River Valley, Williamsport, Daniel Hughes, and personal oral stories from Mamie Diggs, provided by Lynn Estomin. Thank you all for your support, and tune in to part 2 for our recordings of the interviews!
Episode 95
The House of Many Stairs and the Underground Railroad: Part 2
Shanna and PJ are joined by listener, Alicia to tour the House of Many Stairs. We talk about the house while playing clips of the owner, Angela, giving us a tour of the house. We learn a lot about the house and even get to deliver some exclusive news about the house's history right here! So take a step back in time as we tour one of the most fascinating places we've ever seen!
Episode 96
The House of Many Stairs and the Underground Railroad: Part 3
On this exciting conclusion to our House of Many Stairs mini series, Shanna, PJ, and Alicia reveal some more secrets about the house! Have you wondered where the rumored legendary tunnel could be that allowed runaway slaves a safe way into and out of the House of Many Stairs? Well, listen in to this finale to find out where it could be, as well as some really great real-life spooky ghost stories from the past and current owners! Special thanks to Dave and Angela Knight for allowing us such an amazing opportunity! Check them out on Facebook or go to their website www.houseofmanystairs.com
Episode 97
The Jean Bonnet Tavern
This week on The Wellhouse Exorcism, PJ takes us to Bedford, PA to discuss the Jean Bonnet Tavern. This once fort-now bed and breakfast has seen a lot in its time - and has the spirits to prove it! Join us as we talk about this amazing stone building and its history.
Episode 98
Oh Gee Willikers, It's the Giwoggle!
Welcome to Clinton County, PA. It is home to lots of really cool things, but did you know it has a monster hidden in its forests? No, it is not a werewolf. No, it is not the Jersey Devil. It is nothing other than the Giwoggle! With a name this silly, PukwuPJ struggles to maintain his composure while Shanna tells the story of this fascinating creature. #giwoggle #clintoncounty #PACryptid #cryptid
Episode 99
Iowa State Penitentiary
On this episode, Shanna and PukwuPJ comb through the various accounts of hauntings of the original Iowa State Penitentiary. With #prisonerescapes #murders #hangings #prisonriots and more, this prison has much to add to its haunted history. So, listen in for a thorough investigation of #iowastatepenitentiary.
Episode 100
Centralia: A Fiery, Burning Hellscape
On this momentous episode, Shanna and PukwuPJ celebrate episode 100! For this special episode, we first start off by thanking all our #listeners and #friends who have made this podcast so successful. Then, we discuss the fiery hellscape that is #Centralia. With a burning #MineFire that started in the 1960s and is still raging today, many families were evicted for their safety. However, all that #NegativeEnergy may have attracted some spirits, or the souls of the past community members live on as shades of their former selves. Listen in and tell us your thoughts on Centralia!
Episode 101
The Bell Witch Part 1: A Haunted History
For this series, Shanna and PukwPJ are joined by the Wellhouse Crew, Psycho Penny and Paranormal Expert Carrie to delve into the mystery that is the Bell Witch. This episode discusses the #BellWitch and the possible explanations of what it could be. Listen in to learn about the Bell family, time period, area, Kate Batts, and more! And, of course, PukwuPJ does the voices for the major players!
Episode 102
The Bell Witch Part 2: The Haunting Begins
On Part 2 of our Bell Witch Mini Series, Psycho Penny, Creepy Carrie, PukwuPJ, and Shanna explore many of the haunted happenings in and around the Bell property over a series of years. What begins as gnawing on bedposts grows into an entity that knows what is happening everywhere, and it seems it can even travel anywhere. With years of documentation and even a visit from Andrew Jackson, this is a #haunting that cannot be easily #debunked. So, listen in to this episode to hear the story of #TheBellWitch and its self-actualization on the farm!
Episode 103
The Bell Witch Part 3: What Did Betsy Do?
On this finale to our #BellWitch series, we conclude by discussing John Bell's death, Betsy's interesting marriage choice, and the possibilities behind the Bell Witch. Could she be a #Tulpa, #Occult creation, or a #demon? The Wellhouse team presents our ideas to you, and we will let you decide!
Episode 104
Halloween Campfire Session
For #Halloween, Nurse Jackie, Psycho Penny, Creepy Carrie, PukwuPJ, and your Ghost of a Host with the Most share their favorite #scarystories around the #campfire. So, grab your favorite fuzzy blanket, a stick and marshmallows, and cozy up to the campfire with us, if you dare!
Episode 105
Martha, Martha, Martha
On this episode, Shanna tells PukwuPJ all about the hauntings at the Martha Washington Hotel and Spa. With a history that spans back to before the #CivilWar this location is reportedly haunted with many different ghosts. From a fated love to a Confederate soldier without a head, this hotel and spa is not for the faint of heart. Would you stay at the #MarthaHotel ? Let us know!
Episode 106
The Berkshire UFO Incident
Do you believe in #aliens and invasions? Well, on this episode, Shanna tells PukwuPJ all about the #BerkshireUFO story of the 1960s. On September 1, 1969, dozens of people allegedly saw this phenomena. To this day, people still hold to their stories of being taken up into the #UFO, losing time, and ending up in different locations before their #abduction. This is a fascinating story that you will enjoy!
Episode 107
Don't Go There: Dyatlov Part 1
PukwuPJ is in charge again! As we head into the cold, wintery months here in PA, we thought it would be fitting to tell this #scarystory from #Russia. The #DyatlovPass Incident has long confounded scientists and hikers. Listen in to our part 1 where PJ sets the story. He introduces the hikers, the climate, and what the searchers found in the weeks after the expedition's disappearance. Decide for yourself if this was #aliens #yetis or something else!